How to use this tool
- Replace the example numbers for Offer A and Offer B with the real ones.
- Use the monthly cost of your health insurance, your commute cost for each day you go in, and the one-way commute time.
- Optionally open the assumptions to set holidays, a tax rate and what an hour of commuting is worth to you.
- Read the table, the verdict and the list of what would change the answer.
How this is calculated
Real annual value = base salary + bonus + employer 401k match + other benefits you value - your yearly health insurance cost - yearly commute cost - tax on salary and bonus (only if you enter a rate) - the value you place on commute time (only if you enter one).
The 401k match is your salary times the match percentage, and it only counts if you contribute enough to receive it. Health cost is your monthly share times 12.
Working days are 5 days times 52 weeks, minus paid time off, minus paid holidays. Office days are working days times the share of the week you go in (5 minus remote days, over 5). Commute cost is the cost per office day times office days, and commute hours are the round-trip minutes times office days.
Effective hourly rate = real annual value divided by hours worked plus hours commuting. This is the number that shows what an hour of your life earns. Hours worked are your weekly hours divided by 5, times working days, so more paid time off raises the hourly rate.
The verdict compares annual value and hourly rate. If they point to different offers, the tool says so, because it means one offer gives more total money and the other gives more per hour of your time. The sensitivity list shows, for the offer that is behind, the salary rise, extra paid days, larger bonus or extra remote days that would close the gap.
Assumptions this tool makes
These are starting values, not facts about your situation. Every one of them can be changed in the tool.
- Everything is pre-tax unless you type a tax rate. The tool contains no tax law, so it does not know about your brackets, your pre-tax health deductions or 401k contribution limits.
- 10 paid public holidays a year, and a 5 day working week. Change the holidays in the assumptions.
- Benefits are valued at the dollar amount you give. Employer health contributions are not added, only your own premium is subtracted.
- An hour of commute is worth $0 to you unless you enter a figure. The commute still lowers the effective hourly rate.
- The example offers are made up so the page has something to show.
Frequently asked questions
Is the higher salary always the better offer?
No. A lower salary with a better 401k match, cheaper health insurance, more paid time off and a shorter or remote commute can be worth more in total and per hour. This calculator puts those on the same scale.
How do I value a 401k match?
Count it as extra pay equal to the match percentage times your salary, but only if you would contribute enough to get it. If you would not, enter 0 for the match.
How is the effective hourly rate worked out?
Real annual value divided by the hours you work plus the hours you spend travelling to work. It rewards extra paid time off and remote days, because they raise value without adding hours.
Does it handle taxes?
Only through a rate you type. By default it compares before tax. Tax rules vary by place and situation, so enter your own estimate if you want an after-tax view.
What about equity, stability and growth?
They matter and the tool does not score them. You can add a dollar amount for them in other benefits you value, but treat that number with caution.